Showing posts with label audio_amps. Show all posts
Showing posts with label audio_amps. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 16, 2014

Featured VT: 6CB6

 

The 6CB6 was originally designed for high frequency work, especially as an IF amp for TV sets operating at 45MHz. You can see here that the plate consists of parallel planes on opposite sides of a wide, flat cathode. The plates are spaced far from the grids in order to minimize internal device capacitance. The type has a fairly high gm, though not as high as some other types used for high frequency and/or wideband work. It also features an unusually high VHK spec that can make it useful for other purposes, such as DC error amps, or DC coupled LTP's. As for audio performance, this loadline looks quite good.

 

Who Says Pents Have to Make High Order Harmonics

 

This particular loadline shows that h3 and h4 are equal to 0: this produces h2 only. If you don't require the full output swing, the distortion decreases proportionately. If used as an LTP with active tail loading, this would be a clean gain stage indeed. The excellent audio loadlines have lead to the use of the 6CB6 in both professional (one example is given in the RCA Receiving Tube Manual) and DiY designs. It isn't exactly an audio "sleeper", but not audiophool expensive either. It also comes in some odd heater voltages: the 3CB6 (3.15V/0.6A) and the 4CB6 (4.2V/0.45A) the latter types intended for use with TV sets that didn't include a PTX and daisy chained the heaters across the AC mains. This should keep them available.

Tuesday, March 12, 2013

Featured VT: The 50C5

 

50C5

 

If you were there back in the "good ol' days", you saw 'em in almost every cheap AM radio, some really bad FM rigs, those cheap record players you gave the kids so's they'd keep their mitts off the really good stereo or Hi-Fi, home intercoms/PAs, low power guitar "practice" amps.

Those memories are likely to be less than fond ones. Everything the 50C5 appeared in sounded really bad. It wasn't just due to the single-ended pentode topology (which is bad enough) the non-use of any sort of corrective NFB, but the use of really hideous OPTs. These were always tiny affairs, usually riveted right to the speaker's basket, and with a low end frequency of maybe 200Hz (this being done deliberately to attenuate the 60Hz hum that universally plagued these thingies). The spec sheet doesn't even mention push-pull, and it's pretty obvious from the plate characteristics that Class A1 was what was intended from the get-go.

There is another side to the 50C5, and one the manufacturers definitely intended. Unlike most pentodes, the spec sheet includes plate characteristics for both 110VDC and 90VDC on the screens. The plate characteristics for V2K= 90VDC are a good deal more linear. It is also a convenient voltage as this is what the VR-90 voltage regulator tube produces.

50C5 PP Loadline

PP 50C5 Loadline

 

With some slight spec-busting, it is indeed possible to find a really decent PP, Class A1 loadline. Here, you're getting almost seven watts of output, and with a very small H3 estimate. Since the 50C5 was intended to stay in Class A1, that brings up another possibility: use the PP finals as an LTP phase splitter. A 60mA CCS in the tail will sacrifice some power, as you'll get just a bit over three watts if you do this. Restricting the output swing will also improve on distortion performance.

This could be a good solution to a low power requirement, such as computer speaker/amps, or a small stereo amp., especially if you have efficient speeks and don't need a whole lot of power anyway. Of course, if you did this, you would need premium OPTs, and definitely not any OPT designed back in "the day" for 50C5s. Those OPTs were universally hideous. That probably means a custom job (you can get these from Electra Print for a reasonable price).

This is another type that's widely available due to the sheer numbers of them made back in "the day", they don't have that "audiophool premium", and they're not terribly expensive. There is just one word of caution: UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES ATTEMPT TO RUN ANY PROJECT DIRECTLY FROM THE AC MAINS. Yeah, it was done often back then (AC/DC operation meant no PTX). That is likely to ruin equipment due to "hot" chassis, cross-connected AC mains that meant short circuit, and could even get you killed. It was a really bad idea then, and it's still a really bad idea today. You can light up your 50C5s with a cheap "doorbell" transformer: connect its 12V secondary to a 5.0V secondary on your PTX, and you will get 50V from the backwards connected doorbell transformer.

50C5-oids

50B5 -- This type has the same characteristics, but there was a problem with it since it used the 7BZ pinout (same as the 6AQ5) that put the plate connection right next to a heater connection. The 50C5's 7CV pinout puts the plate connection on the opposite side. This was done due to flash-over problems. When the filaments are series connected across the AC mains, the cold heaters don't drop the voltage.

25C5 -- 25V/0.3A heater version, otherwise the same characteristics

17C5 -- 16.8V/0.45A heater

12C5 -- 12.6V/0.6A heater

6CU5 -- 6.3V/1.2A heater (This is the 6.3V version despite the extra letter. 6C5 was already taken: an Octal, singleton triode.)

The 35C5 definitely is not a 35V "50C5", as there is no such thing. It's a different type with different characteristics, even though it was often used for the same purposes as the 50C5. It doesn't have quite the plate dissipation spec, and the characteristics look less linear.

Featured VT: The 6X8

6X8

 

This is one of those odd types that were designed for a very specific purpose: a local oscillator/mixer for both VHF TV sets and FM radios. As you can see from the pinout, this type uses a common cathode for the triode and pentode. Also, it is not built the way you would expect: one triode and one pentode with the cathodes internally tied together. The 6X8 has but one flat cathode. The two types share it, with the control grids mounted on opposite sides of the single cathode.

 

6X8 Pinout

 

You may be wondering: what the hell is it good for? In audio applications, not a great deal. Except for one thing, that is. The 6X8 can be used as an unbalanced differential amp for active screen regulators, and other series pass regulators. The pentode half is capable of some considerable gain, the VHK rating isn't half bad, coming in at 100VDC (both polarities) and could be used without heater lift if using VR-75 or VR-90 types as voltage references.

 

Regulator

 

In this schemo, the triode half forms the non-inverting input, with the "signal" consisting of the voltage developed across the VR tube. The pentode forms the NFB summing node and error correction amp. This regulator topology has the advantages over the more conventional designs since there is no load on the VR tube. The noise can be reduced by a simple RC lowpass filter. This prevents the possibility of inadvertently making as oscillator by connecting a bypass capacitor directly across the VR tube. (Not like Zeners, since the VR tube depends on a glow discharge that has negative resistance.)

I have used this actual design, and it works nearly as well as its solid state counterpart. Varying the DC rail voltage by some 40V caused a 0.8V drop in the output from the regulator. When using pentodes as power finals, sonic performance is definitely improved by good screen voltage regulation, assuming you're not using Ultralinear, or pseudotrioding the pents. This is where commercial designs cut corners: very few commercial (or even industrial) designs did anything more than use a voltage divider to supply the screens. Most relied on a single series dropping resistor. YUCK! That's the advantage to DiY: we don't have to answer to the pencil-pushers in the Accounting Dept.

You can also use the 6X8 as a "quick 'n' dirty" floating paraphase, but you wouldn't want to use that anyway if you're looking for sonic excellence. It could save some Miller capacitance since the triode half, operating as essentially a cathode follower, has no Miller capacitance. However, would that save enough to make a difference? That's what pentodes were invented for in the first place. The exception would be a guitar amp, and the 6X8 just might find some good use there.

As with any high gain pentode circuit, care must be taken with the construction if instabilities are to be avoided. This includes grid and screen stoppers. If these aren't needed, no harm done, but if there are instabilities, they are definitely necessary. Keep all connecting leads short as possible, as for an RF project, use sockets that include a central pin, and connect it to the ground plane for electrostatic shielding. The screen bypass capacitor can likewise be installed across the bottom of the socket, between the plate and grid connections, for additional electrostatic shielding.

Getting more use from "useless" Tee-Vee T00bz. They're cheap, they're out there, light 'em up!

Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Featured VT: 6LR8

6LR8 I had a few of these come my way: the 6LR8. This is a triode/pentode originated for use as a combination plate coupled multivibrator and vertical deflection amp. For a vertical deflection type, the ratings come in pretty stiff: PD= 14W for the pentode power final. I drew up some loadlines, and these do indeed look promising: 6LR8 Loadline The h3 estimate is quite low, and it doesn't seem to be too far into Class AB2. If there are any problems with higher order harmonics, and I wouldn't be expecting these anyway since vertical deflection duty values good linearity in the finals. Any residual pentode nastiness can easily be tamed by means of local NFB. A PP pair could easily do 30W into a quite reasonable 6K (P-2-P) load, and stock Edcors come quite close to that anyway. Conveniently, the same envelope includes a small signal, high-μ triode. Its characteristics look linear enough for audio amp duty, and you could use them to form an LTP driver, or use them as grid driver cathode followers. Though I'd prefer the latter, as there are better small signal audio triodes for front end/phase splitter duty. The VHK ratings also high enough so that cathode follower duty isn't going to be a problem in that regard. The possible drawbacks are that Novar (large nine pin) base, and the rather stiff heater current requirement. Those pins are awfully thin to be pumping 1.5A through them. You also have to be careful when selecting sockets. There are all too many cheaply made Novar bases with the holes out of alignment. If you have to force the pins into the socket, that's just begging for a failure of the glass seals. Letting out the vacuum, especially when powered up, will certainly have some pyrotechnic displays, and possibly catastrophic failures elsewhere. The other good thing about the type is that it is also available in some odd heater voltages originally intended for operation as a series string across the AC mains. 21LR8 -- 21V/0.45A 31LR8 -- 31.5V/0.3A These types are definitely cheaper, and probably more available due to reduced demand. You could either wind your own heater xfmrs, or have custom jobs (Edcor) make them up for you. As with all these TV deflection pents, the screen grid ratings are low enough to make pseudotriode and UL operation impractical. Another definite audio "sleeper" that didn't have audio final use mentioned in the spec sheet.

Thursday, January 17, 2013

Featured VTs: The 6BQ6

 

The 6BQ6 as an audio final came to my attention as a chance result of finding an old article from a Portuguese (Brazilian? -- it was written in Portuguese) ham magazine. This described a simple AM plate modulator that claimed an output of 30W (fixed bias) or 25W (cathode bias) that used a push-pull pair of these VTs. You would expect to see 6L6s or 807s used in this particular application. Why 6BQ6s, and what were they?

The 6BQ6 is a large signal beam former. It has no audio pedigree whatsoever, and the spec sheet makes no mention of its use as an audio final. During the 1950s, screen sizes and deflection angles increased, giving a larger viewing area, and a shorter CRT for more compact TV sets. This development meant that the usual audio finals and RF types became increasingly unsatisfactory for horizontal deflection duty. New types more suited to the task were developed, and one such type was the 6BQ6, in several different iterations for large screen, B & W TV sets.

The 6BQ6, as with all HD types, is capable of pulling big currents through the horizontal deflection coils. This was accomplished by cathodes much larger than those found in comparable audio and RF finals, such as the 6L6-oids. Compare heater voltages and currents:

6V6: 6.3V / 0.45A (2.835W)
6L6: 6.3V / 0.9A (5.67W)
6BQ6: 6.3V / 1.2A (7.56W)

This makes possible a maximum cathode current spec of 400mA. In terms of solid state, that isn't very spectacular, but for a nominally high voltage, low current device, it's pretty good. Other design features include a low voltage capability, made possible by the close proximity of screen grids to the cathode, and that's what you want for drawing big currents through deflection coils, and for operation from transformerless power supplies that derive the working DC directly from the AC mains. The latter consideration has spawned versions of this tube with odd heater voltages for operation in series heater strings.

As an audio final, the high current and low voltage capabilities make for lower load impedances, and therefore, for easier to design OPTs. The lack of any audio final usage requires one to draw up loadlines to find suitable operating points. Here is one such audio loadline:

6BQ6 25mA Loadline

As you can see, the load is just 1K1 per phase. This is a Class AB loadline, so you would need an OPT with a primary that can match 4K4 (P-2-P) to your speaker load. It's is a good deal easier to manufacture an OPT with excellent high and low frequency performance than it would be for the 10K (P-2-P) load a PP pair of 6V6s need. It's also a convenient value since there are off-the-shelf OPTs that were designed for Class A, PP, 6L6s that match this value. The only drawback to using one of these OPTs is that they are a bit under powered for the 6BQ6.

As for why no audio uses are specced, the plate characteristic tells all. It is not possible to use the 6BQ6 in Class A. The most linear part of that characteristic lies well within red plate territory. You are committed to Class AB, push-pull only. That isn't necessarily a bad thing, though.

If you stick with the usual convention for determining the static plate bias current, you are deep into Class AB. The closer you come to Class B conditions, the more cross-over distortion you have. The estimated H3= 5.0% is barely acceptable. There is something you can do about this. The 6BQ6 was specced very conservatively, since its main purpose is to output max RMS power for hours a day, all the while maintaining a reasonable service life. Audio amplification is a good deal less demanding. If you increase the bias, and bust the plate dissipation spec, the performance improves greatly.

50mA Loadline

Doubling the bias current to 50mA per plate, makes for 17.5W of static dissipation: exceeding the spec by 6.5W (the 6BQ6 is rated close to the 6V6). This is of no consequence, as you don't get any color on the plates. The RCA gray plates can handle up to 70mA, with just a trace of color. The Sylvania black plates aren't showing any color even at this extreme 24.5W of static plate dissipation. 50mA of bias won't harm this type, even if it's outside of the spec. The increased bias current, and the much lower H3 estimate, does make a noticeable -- and improved -- sonic difference in practice.

As to the sonic performance of the type that had no audio pedigree, in a word: excellent. The 6BQ6 easily matches the performance of the legendary 6V6, and it pumps out more than twice the power. Running open loop, the 6BQ6 doesn't have any of that expected "pentode nastiness" until it's nearly at the point of clipping. There's just an "edginess" or "aggressiveness" to the sound. That would account for why the Portuguese (Brazilian?) hams elected to use it in their plate modulator project (it was an open loop design). 6L6s tend to sound much worse open loop.

The Twin-T test also bears this out. After nulling the fundamental, the residual is almost a perfect sine wave at three times the frequency. There is little higher order harmonic components. Though high fidelity isn't legal on the ham bands, the 6BQ6 plate modulator would indeed sound better. For excellent sonic performance, all that's required is enough gNFB to take off the edge. The 6BQ6, like the 6V6, doesn't require the additional help of local NFB. That is a good thing in that the low screen voltage spec pretty much eliminates Ultralinear. Operate them in full pentode mode with a regulated screen supply. As with any pent that can't run the plate and screen at the same potential, the best sonic performance results when the screen voltage is tightly regulated, and supplied from a source with a very low impedance, as is the case with an active regulator.

The 6BQ6 also seems to be a good deal more stable in operation. It doesn't produce the snivets that are seen with other types, even if you don't include plate and screen stoppers. Even if not strictly necessary, it does no harm to include these anyway. Screen stoppers can be 680Ω/0.5W C-comp resistors. Plate stoppers can be made from ten turns of #18 wire, space wound 7/16ths inch ID, with 100Ω/2W (or four 470Ω/0.5W C-comps in parallel) de-Qing resistors mounted inside the coil. That should take care of any possible instabilities, or tendencies to make RF, due to lay-out issues.

6BQ6-oids:

This type appeared early on in TV development. The first iterations were in ST glass. As TV screens got bigger, new versions appeared. The 6BQ6GTA has the small profile, tubular glass envelope. This type has smaller cathodes, and is not quite so robust as later iterations. As such, it will red plate badly if used at the Q-Points mentioned previously.

The 6BQ6GTB has the same small diameter envelope, but does work as described above. The 6BQ6GA has a larger bottle, but otherwise biases identically to the 6BQ6GTB. As for sonic performance, the 6BQ6GA may have a slight sonic edge, but I'm not 100% certain of that. Either version sounds great, and will stand up to the spec busting for long service life in audio amplification applications, which is what we're interested in here. Of course, audio amplification is not the same as horizontal deflection duty, or "brick on the key" RF modes (FM, Packet) either.

The 6BQ6 really is a tougher, higher powered, 6V6. The main difference is the greatly reduced screen voltage spec that precludes Ultralinear, and makes pseudotrioding problematic. As a pseudotriode, since the screen voltage never exceeds the plate voltage, you may be able to get away with running at higher than specced screen voltages without either poofing the screens or plate current run-away. That remains to be seen, if you're so inclined to experiment with it.

The advent of TV sets running transformerless power supplies has also led to the development of *BQ6s that have some odd heater voltages:

12BQ6: 12.6V / 0.6A
25BQ6: 25V / 0.3A

These types were intended for use in series strings, as there was no PTX to provide heater power. That such types exist is beneficial in case the 6.3V version should become harder to acquire, and/or the price becomes excessive. Five years ago, you could get 6BQ6s for under a dollar a pop. Due to inflation, and probably the publication of designs that use the type, the prices have been going up. Still, it's not like audiophool expensive, even for quality that's dubious, of finals that do have that audio pedigree. Availability should not be a problem, since the 6BQ6 was widely used in a great many brands of wide screen, B & W TV sets.

6AV5 and Other HD VTs:

This type is very close to the 6BQ6 in terms of specs and sonic performance. The main difference is that the 6AV5 lacks a top cap connection to the plate. This would be a plus for designers who're leery of plate top caps in audio amps that potentially expose end users to dangerous voltages.

If you can wind your own OPTs, or don't mind paying extra to have custom OPTs wound, other possibilities present themselves. As B & W screens increased in size, new types that could handle the increased current demand were developed. This would include types such as the 6CB5 and 6DQ5 -- both capable of even higher output power.

With the advent of color TV, the demands put upon horizontal deflection subsystems grew even greater: color TV CRTs operate at much higher voltages, require more cathode current, and also had the large screens and deflection angles. To meet these demands, some truly awesome power tubes were developed for increased current sourcing, and power handling.

36LW6

This beast is the 36LW6: Pd= 40W, Imax= 1.75A

It was one of the last generation of Octal HD finals before the advent of the Duodecar (12 pins) and Novar (9 pins) all glass tubes that began to appear during the early 1960s. Part of this development was to allow for putting more tubes in the same envelope. You had a single bottle that might include two RF pentodes for TV IF amps, or combination power triodes and small signal triodes for vertical deflection duty, or triode/pentodes for sync sep/horizontal deflection time bases. FM demodulator/audio voltage amps and power pentodes were likewise included in the same bottle. It was common to put the HD final and the damper diode in the same bottle.

The 6.3V version has become extremely difficult to find these days since a good many were diverted to ham use as RF finals. Even worse was the diversion to illegal CB linears during the mid-1970s CB craze. These illegal rigs were all too frequently badly designed, and poofed the finals too quickly. However, there are quite a few still available if you go with the odd heater voltages, and the prices aren't exorbitant either. You'll have to either wind your own heater PTXs, or have them custom wound. The characteristics remain the same. This type was also designed for operation from a DC rail derived from a transformerless voltage doubler. The spec sheet mentions that it needs just 280VDC to work, and the published plate characteristic doesn't extend beyond that particular voltage. That would account for the variety of heater voltages. This is a definite benefit for audio design: low load resistance, and the avoidance of high plate voltages.

36LW6 Loadline

This looks promising indeed. That's nearly 95W of audio power from a single pair of PP finals, running conservatively, and with a Vpp= 300VDC. It is helpful that the grid voltage swing isn't out of line with the more common audio power pents, as this allows for lower distortion from the front end. A good many power finals for RF use in particular would need to run at twice -- or more -- the DC plate voltage and likely Class AB2 operation. Getting that much audio power would require PP-parallel operation of the more usual audio power finals running Class AB1.

The estimated H3 for this loadline comes in at about 0.2%. That bodes well for sonic performance. Given the low screen voltages, there is another possible way to use this: screen drive. Use a MOSFET source follower to drive the screen grid, with the control grid bypassed to AC ground, and used only to set a Q-Point current. This becomes a type of Class AB2 operation that can boost the output power while maintaining a reasonable plate dissipation. It is also helpful in that the screen current remains low until the Vpk is taken to very low levels indeed.

I'm definitely going to have to give this a go some day.

Friday, April 30, 2010

The Weak Link

The major problem with hollow state is that the vacuum tube is a high voltage, low current -- and therefore Hi-Z -- device. Electromechanical speakers are just the opposite: requiring high currents at relatively low voltages. The usual solution to this problem is the impedance matching transformer. Unfortunately, no transformer that has a ferromagnetic core is a linear device. Air core transformers that can operate at audio frequencies are not exactly efficient, and what you gain in core linearity you promptly lose in the enormous stray capacitance that the huge number of turns such a thing would require.

So the ideal situation would be to get rid of that transformer completely. There are a couple of factors that go against this: the Hi-Z nature of the device itself, and the fact that there is no such thing as a "P-Channel" VT. Given that, you are limited to some sort of "totem pole" output stage. Here, the problem is the lack of symmetry: one half will be acting as a grounded cathode amp with its characteristic voltage gain, while the other half will be, more or less, working as a cathode follower with its less than unity voltage gain. There have been various attempts to deal with this problem such as asymmetrical drive -- the SEPP output, or the Futterman variations that include feedback to either make the cathode follower half behave more like the grounded cathode half, or the inverted Futterman that applies NFB to the grounded cathode half to make it look more like a cathode follower.

There is another topology that at least takes care of the balance problem: the Wiggins Circlotron design, this being a bridged output stage. Even though originated for use with an OPT for the purpose of eliminating Class AB switching transients from the primary, it also makes for a very good OTL design as well.

The other problem remains: the low current nature of the VT itself. You really don't have much choice here, so far as possible types are concerned.

There have been VTs that were intended to give some serious output currents, these being the horizontal deflection finals. Even though the screen voltage specs limit the screen voltage to rather low levels, these can still pull some serious current at lowish VPK's. Still, you are going to have to parallel up individual units in order to get the necessary output currents. The 6BQ6GTB can easily pull some 350mA of peak current when the plate and screen both operate at 150VDC, if you go a bit into Class AB2. For 30W of output into 8R, it will still require 16 6BQ6GTBs (8 per phase). That's a bit too much.

Other possible types would include the 6C33C (Series pass regulator used on the MiG fighter). There have been a lot of problems concerning this type, as its reliability is questionable, even with the special "burn-in" trick. Also, the pins are way too thin for the heater current requirement. MiG technicians replace not just the 6C33Cs, but also the socket as part of routine maintenance. I would avoid it.

The most likely type is the 6AS7 (and its relatives: 6080, industrial type, or the 6082, 26.5V heater version) -- another type originated as a series pass regulator tube. As such, it has the high current capability with reasonable VPK's, and it is also a dual triode, so that you require half the number of bottles. Though its plate characteristics aren't spectacular, they aren't half bad either. It's not likely you'd want to use this in a conventional output circuit as there are better power triodes for that. Still, the 6AS7 can pull significant currents without taking the control grid positive. Eight 6AS7s (16 sections, 8 per phase) can get you 30W of output without serious spec busting. The type is also well known for having a high gm and a very low rp. The 6AS7 has been used to drive VT Class B audio output stages (AM plate modulators) for a very long time now.

Does getting rid of the OPT really represent an improvement in overall linearity? What you might gain in one area, you might lose back in another: operating the VTs into a very steep loadline (eight sections in parallel to drive 8 ohms is just 64 ohms per section). You might be just as well off in substituting MOSFETs for the hollow state output. There have been some complaints that paralleling finals leads to sonic degradation, since the individual VTs won't all be operating at precisely the same currents with the same exact characteristics. Whether or not this makes a difference is a whole 'nother story. At least the very low (for hollow state) impedance of the 6AS7 does help to mitigate this effect. This is another one of those areas where you just might have to try it to see and make up your own mind if it's worth it.

As for trying this, it is definitely something to take a shot at. It is especially helpful in that the 6AS7 is a current production VT, and at least in this case, the new production is superior to NOS offerings: better matching between sections, and a more robust design that will stand up to the slight spec-busting that can reduce the number of triode sections per phase. The 0.125A plate/cathode current rating is for DC regulator use. That peak current can be increased to 0.375A in audio final use. Music and voice programs won't be spending very much time at the maximum peak current. (It would be a different story for DC use or continuous max PRMS applications. (If you were doing that, then consider the 0.125A spec to be a DC/RMS value.)

The only other requirements are DC offset detection/correction since you definitely want to keep DC out of speaker voice coils, fault detection in case one 6AS7 (or one section of a 6AS7) develops some fault that causes it to pull more current, and HV delay. Being that the intended purpose was series pass duty, the heater-to-cathode insulation is a good deal thicker to stand up to higher than normal voltages. This also slows down greatly the cathode warm-up, and the specs call for preheating to make sure the cathodes are at operating temp before hitting 'em with the HV.

The specs also strongly discourage the use of fixed bias. The problem of using the much more desirable fixed bias can be solved by mixed fixed/cathode bias, and over current detection. A 6AS7, OTL, Circlotron design is definitely "in the works".

Sunday, April 18, 2010

Common Amplifier Myths

 



You Should Always Use (Some Brand) of Tubes



There is seldom any reason to pay premium prices for "special" VTs. I'm certain that Western Electric NOS 300Bs are quite decent tubes. I'm also certain that they are not worth the $High Four Figure prices these command. You can see certain types going for some ridiculous prices these days. That's nothing but pure audiophoolery. Put an over priced tube in a mediocre amp, and you still have a mediocre amp. "NOS" is also not necessarily the magic word either. Back in "the day" good, bad, and indifferent tubes rolled off the assembly lines by the tens of thousands every day. Some war surplus is positively hideous, which is why it's surplus -- military rejects. Truth is: some NOS tubes are horrible, and there are current production tubes that are every bit as good as those made in "the good ol' days".


This is not to say that the seller is necessarily trying to put one over (although that does happen all too often). The advertised tubes may work especially well with whatever equipment he's using. It doesn't mean equivalent performance in random gear with random speakers.


"Tube rolling" does have a basis in fact. Unlike transistors, VTs are low gain devices. Being low gain devices, circuit performance is more dependent on the characteristics of the active device. Transistors have so much gain that circuit performance is totally dependent on the circuit itself. Unless you need some special property (such as an unusually low noise figure, or that can operate at unusually high voltages) it doesn't matter what transistors you use so long as the transistor in question can process the signal frequencies. Not so with tubes, especially in designs that don't incorporate any NFB. You may get a different sound from different tubes of different construction, name brands, model years. Whether it's worth it or not is something else.


It is not necessary to pay audiphool silly prices for good sound.



Point-to-point is Good, Circuit Boards are Bad



This is definitely true for RF circuits. For P-2-P wiring, the insulating medium is air. The resulting stray capacitance is much lower, and performance definitely enhanced. This is a good reason to opt for "dead bug" or P-2-P construction of RF circuits. At audio frequencies, there isn't enough of a difference in stray capacitance to make a difference. P-2-P has the advantage of allowing the free use of "parts on hand". Circuit boards have the advantage of easily replicated construction, and much better quality control for mass production. To be sure, a badly laid out circuit board will ruin the sonic performance of an otherwise excellent design. So too will a poorly laid out P-2-P job.



If You Use Circuit Boards, These Should be Teflon



Again, a good idea for UHF circuits, but the savings in stray capacitance will make no difference at audio frequencies.



You Should Always Use Teflon Insulated Silver Wire



Another excellent idea for UHF construction. The tiny savings in resistance and stray capacitance will make no difference at audio frequencies. The added expense isn't worth it for frequencies as low as the audio band.



You Should Always Use Carbon Composition Resistors



Another idea held over from RF practice. C-comp resistors have the advantage of having a very low inductance. C-comps hold their DC resistance well into the VHF band. Otherwise, C-comps are very noisy. Save them for your RF projects. Metal film resistors are a good deal quieter, and better suited for sensitive applications, such as low level stages. Those few nanohenries that are a big deal at 400MHz are of no consequence at 400Hz.



Negative Feedback is Bad



This bit of nonsense does have a basis in fact. In all too many cases, NFB is used to cover up a poor open loop design. Pour on enough NFB and you can sweep your mistakes under the carpet, along with a good deal of the vitality of the music. This, however, is not an indictment of NFB. Used properly -- to improve an already good open loop design -- NFB can make a good amp even better. This is the key: the open loop design must be a good one. If you find that you need excessive amounts of NFB, then it's better to go back to the drawing board and correct your open loop design. All too frequently, this is not the case.


Furthermore, there is no escaping NFB. Every device, vacuum tubes or transistors of every sort, have inherent NFB. This is the cathode/source/emitter resistance: r~= 1/gm. This resistance will cause degeneration just as surely as if it were an unbypassed resistor soldered into the circuit. Just because you don't see it doesn't mean it's not there. Furthermore, triodes have an additional feedback mechanism. Plate current is dependent on the VPK. When a signal tries to pull the control grid positive, plate current rises, but the VPK drops and tries to pull the plate current down. Since the plate and grid are pulling in opposite directions, this is negative feedback by definition. Yet triodes are preferred to every active device that doesn't have this property (pentodes and transistors).


If anyone claims to have a "no feedback" design, they're either ignorant or trying to put one over -- or what's worse: both.



Solid State is the Spawn of the Devil



Another partial truth here. The first solid state amps were truly awful: noisy, unreliable, and with hideous sonics. There has never been a technology with no down side, and there never will be. There are some things that SS does very well, and some things it does very poorly. The key is balancing the strengths with the weaknesses. The only reason to avoid all solid state is if you are replicating 1930s-era equipment for the nostalgia appeal. Otherwise, do you also say "No" to modern line, interstage, and output transformers and chokes that are made from exotic materials that didn't exist in the 1930s? All these devices can perform much better these days, and make those old circuits work much better now than they ever could then.



With zero impedance and perfect regulation, plate-circuit distortion does not exceed 2.0%... The driver stage should be capable of supplying the grids of the Class AB2 stage with the specified peak grid voltage at low distortion. The effective resistance per grid should not exceed 500 ohms...



-- 1624 Spec Sheet



Back in "the day", this was asking the nearly impossible. Getting Zo below 500 ohms is very difficult even for a cathode follower, unless it uses some of the big power triodes. These days, any power MOSFET source follower can come very close to the ideal of zero drive impedance, certainly below 10 ohms. Use solid state where it gets the job done right. The fact that it was a considerable challenge is testified to by the lack of Hi-Fi designs left over from "the day" that operate Class AB2. Most of the designs that did are for AM plate modulators and PA systems where the premiums were lotsawatts and efficiency, not sonic performance. These days, there is no reason not to take advantage of going Class AB2.


Another bit of mythology is the supposed noise that solid state diodes cause. Except for audiophile circles, I have never heard such a claim. Furthermore, I haven't seen it on the o'scope screen and I have never heard it from any receiver operated right next to any audio amp that used a solid state power supply. Gas and mercury vapor diodes, however, are notorious for producing all sorts of hash and incidental RF. Otherwise, solid state diodes offer much lower forward drops, don't get anywhere near as hot, have significantly higher Isurge ratings, and require neither heater power nor another hole in the chassis. They better lend themselves to voltage multiplier circuits, and bridged circuits. If you are that worried about high frequency noise from solid state diodes, the "fix" is a two or three pole LPF made from air coils and mica capacitors. Won't do any harm, but it sure doesn't look necessary either.


If there is any down side to solid state, it's that the high voltage comes up within a couple of seconds or so -- long before cathodes have a chance to warm up. This can overvolt direct coupled stages, possibly exceeding VHK ratings. Since silicon diodes can source much higher currents, there is the temptation to use them with huge reservoir capacitors. The increased current demand can stress vintage power transformers that weren't designed to handle currents in excess of those expected from vacuum diodes.


A solid state power supply may or may not lead to a different sound. If there is a difference, it's due to the better voltage regulation of the solid state power supply. For some applications, good regulation isn't desirable. This would apply to over driven guitar amps where the voltage drop at max current demand lends to compression, and "sustain" as the voltage comes back up. The same effect can color the sound of a Hi-Fi system. If you're used to that sound, or actually prefer it, then, of course, solid state will be considered inferior.


It is questionable whether it makes a difference in a PP amp since the AC sums to zero at the primary center tap, making it a virtual AC ground. It might make more of a difference in a SE design, since the power supply is in the signal path. Even more reason to use solid state, as the AC impedance is considerably lower.



Tube Watts are Bigger than Transistor Watts



A watt is a watt: one newton * meter per second. Transistors clip hard and fast. This is what makes them superior digital devices, but horrible analog devices. Add NFB, and clip behavior becomes even worse. Tubes clip much more gently, first simply rounding off the peaks, as opposed to just flattening them. This gradual rounding generates mainly low order harmonics that roll off quickly with increasing frequency. The sharp discontinuities of peak flattening generates high order harmonics that roll off gradually with increasing frequency. Since low order harmonics are much less detrimental, one doesn't hear the occasional clip on fast transients. A solid state amp needs to stay out of clipping. Therefore, a tube amp will sound louder than an equivalent solid state amp, since you don't hear the occasional clip, you can turn up the volume higher before obvious distortion is heard.



Tube Amps Have Poorer Bass



This may have been true at one point. One of the advantages to NFB is that it reduces the output impedance. A low output impedance is needed to damp the woofers, otherwise they will tend to produce their own resonance note, as opposed to the notes the musician actually played. Back in "the day", the main problem here was inadequate open loop bandwidth. You can have a billiard table flat frequency response from 30Hz to 20KHz, however, if it's NFB that's causing it, the bass will not be as good as you'd expect. If the open loop response prematurely rolls off the low end, the NFB decreases, thus driving up the closed loop gain. Less NFB is less effective NFB, and won't dampen the woofer(s) properly. This problem was due to interstage coupling capacitors that were too small. At one time, your choice for capacitors was limited to either PiO, wax paper, or ceramic. PiO and wax tend to be leaky (not the oil or wax, but of current) and deteriorated with age. Ceramic wasn't leaky, but also didn't come in the sizes and voltage ratings you'd like to see. Consequently, there wasn't enough open loop gain at the low end.


These days, with new polymers, it is possible to get capacitors in the sizes and voltage ratings you need for good open loop performance at the low end. Vacuum tube amps can have good bass, with adequate speaker damping. (About the only exceptions are sub-woofers with ceramic or carbon fiber cones and heavy voice coils. These sub-woofers are difficult for even a solid state amp to keep under control.)



"Magic" Resistors



Yet another out growth of a real phenomenon. During the early 1970s, it was discovered that capacitors really did have an effect on sonics. Up till this point, no one really paid any attention to passive components. They knew about such things as ESR, DF, Loss Tangents -- however it was only VHF designers who needed to worry about this. Capacitors introduce distortions, due to D/E field nonlinearities, piezoelectric effects, and even self-excited resonances. So far as dielectrics go, the worst offenders tend to be metal oxides (ceramics, electrolytics) and other high permittivity materials. The more benign being the polypropylenes and teflons. Unfortunately, these are also materials with low permittivities, and so do not lend themselves to packing a lot of capacitance in small packages.


While dielectrics have a proved effect on sonic performance, this has also occasioned a lot of audiophoolery. From legitimate claims about the effects of various dielectrics with data to back the claims up, to utter nonsense regarding the "sound" of resistors. There are lots of claims with zero data about the superior attributes (available at superior $Prices) of these things. Don't be conned into paying dollars for some part that would normally cost pennies.


If you see extravagant claims with nothing more than vague generalities backing them up, better get a tighter grip on your wallet.



Component "Burn-In"



You see these claims about a variety of components: they require X number of hours of "burn-in" before they start to sound good. This is complete nonsense. Capacitors polarize within seconds of the voltage application. I've seen claims of 100 -- 500 hours for Teflon capacitors, and with AuriCaps. The first time I replaced an electrolytic coupling capacitor with an AuriCap, I noticed the improvement at once. Of course, electrolytics make lousy signal capacitors, and AuriCaps are pretty good. There was no "burn-in" required at all.


Resistors sometimes burn out, but they never "burn-in". As for cables, well, you figure that one out. The only components that require a certain amount of "burn-in" are vacuum tubes. It may take minutes to hours for the bias to settle down when new tubes are put in service. This is completely normal, but does not apply to any sort of passive component, nor does it apply to solid state devices at all. Such claims are largely disengenuous, in that the time it takes for the new component to "burn-in" is equal to the time it takes for you to get used to the new (and most likely) inferior sound of whatever over priced, whiz-bang, gizmo you just likely spent way $Too Much to acquire.


Next time you see this particular claim, ask yourself one question: why didn't they burn the thing in at the factory before sending it out the door?

Monday, February 8, 2010

SRPP Demystified

SRPP





There is considerable misunderstanding and mystification regarding this particular circuit, including even what it's called. "SRPP" seems to mean: Shunt Regulated Push Pull, although you see different words assigned to the acronym.

As for what, exactly, this thingy is, it should be immediately recognizable to anyone with a solid state design background: it's an active pull-up/active pull-down circuit. (It greatly resembles the output stage of the TTL family.) The main difference is that it is quasi-complimentary by necessity since there is no such thing as a "P-Channel" VT. This means it is, indeed, push-pull by definition. The upper triode acts to source current to the load, and the lower triode sinks current from the load. As with any push-pull topology, it reduces distortion by nulling even order harmonics.

The big point of departure from solid state is that the SRPP is balanced for three load conditions only: a dead short (makes both triodes into grounded cathode stages -- not very useful) an open circuit (or at least a very high load impedance -- if there is just one path for the current, equal currents must flow through both triodes) and the one impedance for which it was designed. For any other load conditions, the SRPP goes out of balance, and distortion rises, more or less, rapidly. This is OK, considering the purpose for which the SRPP was originated: a line driver. As a line driver, it operates into the characteristic impedance of the T-line.

As an audio circuit, this leaves a lot to be desired. If it works into Class A*1 grids, then it's OK since that's nearly an open circuit. The trouble starts when the driven control grids are driven positive, and draw current. Under grid current conditions, the resulting impedance is neither constant nor linear. This is not the type of load an SRPP wants to see. Including such a driver will lead to poor clipping behaviour. Unfortunately, it is grid current conditions where you'd like to include active pull-up to not only supply that grid current, but supply it from a Lo-Z source to minimize distortion.

You also see SRPPs used as audio finals. This, too, is not the place for this since any speaker represents anything but a constant load. Speaker impedance varies not only in magnitude, but also phase angle. This will play hell with an SRPP, as it will be operating off its optimum load impedance almost all of the time. That will generate lots of avoidable distortion which will require that much more NFB to correct. This is not what you want in good open loop design.

As for how the SRPP develops voltage gain, consider the RP. The far end of that plate load resistor has a cathode follower sitting on top of it. This means that the voltage across that resistor is much less than it would be if connected directly to the DC rail. The effective AC resistance is much higher than its DC resistance. This gives the lower triode more voltage gain that it would otherwise have. The next question becomes: can we make that resistor even larger to increase voltage gain? If you break the DC coupling, the answer is "yes". This gives us the variation called a "Mu stage", so called since its voltage gain can approach the amplification factor (μ) of the lower triode.

Mu Stage





The AC coupling allows for a larger RP since it is no longer doing double duty as a cathode bias resistor. The mu stage no longer has any pretension for being a balanced topology. It is designed for large voltage gains. Is this a useful topology? It was back in "the day", however, it is obsolete and should not be used. Today, we have solid state devices which can operate as excellent CCSs. You will do much better loading a triode with a constant current, as this gives a horizontal loadline that both maximizes output swing, voltage gain, and minimizes harmonic distortion. Back in "the day" we didn't have the ICs, BJTs or MOSFETs that could have made for decent CCSs. Before then, your only other recourse was to use a pentode as a CCS. That would give you something quite mu stage-ish anyway.

If you need lots of gain, then use a solid state CCS. These old fashioned circuits serve no purpose these days, other than nostalgia appeal, or audiophool trendiness on the part of those who like "exotic" circuits for the exoticness.

Sunday, February 7, 2010

Demystifying the Cascode


Basic Cascode





This is what the schemo of the cascode looks like. RK serves to establish the Q-Point bias for the lower triode, and RG is its DC grid return. RP is the passive plate load. The voltage divider connected to the grid of the upper triode establishes its Q-Point bias.

So why would you want to do this? What you have here is a cascade of a grounded cathode stage driving a grounded grid stage. The GC topology has the advantage of a Hi-Z input. However, its high frequency performance is impacted by a high CMiller that only grows worse with increasing voltage gain.

The GG topology avoids CMiller for excellent high frequency performance, but it suffers from a Lo-Z input. It's not very often that a Lo-Z input is desirable. However, you can combine the two in a manner that work together. The Lo-Z of the GG stage loads down the plate of the GC stage, reducing its gain greatly. The lion's share of voltage gain comes from the GG second stage. Reducing the gain reduces CMiller to manageable levels while preserving the Hi-Z input. This gives the cascode a characteristic more like that of a small signal tetrode, with its reduced CMiller, high voltage gain, less the screen grid "kinks", and partition noise. Unlike a tetrode, the VGK of the upper triode remains negative, and so you also don't get the partition noise that tetrode screen grids produce. That's where the name comes from: a contraction of "cascade" and "tetrode".

It is for this reason that the cascode is frequently cited as a VHF small signal amplifier. As for what this means for audio amplification, the reduced CMiller is helpful since a volume pot with a high resistance won't produce the roll-off that bothers designs that place the high gain triode stage up front. The cascode, having higher gain than a single triode gain stage also looked quite useful. As an LTP phase splitter, the cascode could give enough gain to eliminate a second gain stage.

As for sonic performance, there is very little information concerning this. Most of the information I could find related to the design of guitar amps where voltage gain was the emphasis, as distortion is much less of a consideration in such designs. Cascoded LTPs are used quite frequently in solid state designs. However, I could not come up with any examples of hollow state designs that used this topology. Was that just because it was "weird", or required another dual triode, or had this been tried and found to be sonically inferior?

This was another case of try it to find out. As for VT selections, the 6SN7 didn't provide enough gain, and the 12AT7 suffered a fast gm roll-off with decreasing plate current. Digging into the RCA Receiving Tube Manual (RC-30), I came up with the 6BQ7A -- a dual triode designed specifically for cascoding and operation up to 300MHz. Its μ= 38 is considerably higher than that of the 6SN7, but is still reasonable for this particular design. The main problem with the 6BQ7 is that it isn't an audio tube, has no audio use specified in the spec sheet, and has a very peculiar plate characteristic (undocumented variable-μ feature?). Finding a good audio loadline is not so easy, and this type likes to see a VPK that's higher than usual. Still, it looked doable, and since this is a balanced topology, it should greatly reduce harmonic distortion if most of that is h2.

Cascoded LTP Design





There are a couple of bug-a-boos with this topology. The output voltage swing is rather small for the DC rail voltage, the PSRR is less than that of most triode-only gain stages, and the output impedance is very high. This last feature is desirable in an RF amp since that means less loading of LC tuners, and higher loaded Q's. For an audio amp that has to operate over a rather large range of frequencies, it's not such a good thing. A Hi-Z output will interact poorly with the input capacitance of a subsequent stage or other load. To prevent premature roll-off, it is necessary to operate into a Hi-Z, Lo-C load.

The design also uses an active (CCS) tail load. The CCS presents a very high impedance to the junction of the two cathodes. This greatly improves both the phase-to-phase AC balance, and also equalizes the harmonic distortion between phases. It is this distortion imbalance that gives a great many phase splitters inferior sonics. The CCS is a cascode of BJTs. This gives better performance than would the more traditional small signal pentode. The BJT, having much greater gain, gives a higher tail impedance, and a more nearly constant current, with a lower negative rail voltage. This is one area where solid state really is better.

O'scoping the output of the cascode directly resulted in poor square waves with severely tilted tops, indicating a loss of high frequencies. The -3dbv point was barely 20KHz. That's positively horrible! However these were artifacts of the Ci of the o'scope probe, cable, and vertical deflection amp. So this meant it required a "friendlier" load. For that, a cathode follower works nicely. A CF stage has the high input impedance, and the low input capacitance since there is no Miller Effect. Since the voltage at the cathode "follows" the grid, there is very little current through CGK, so this capacitance all but disappears. When operated into a cathode follower, the true picture emerged: nice flat square waves to 10KHz, a -3dbv point of 117KHz, more than enough for an audio amp.

So how did it sound? In a word: excellent. There were no pentode-like artifacts at all, and the sonics were identical to what a good triode LTP would produce. It beats all the paraphase splitters in their various iterations. This definitely should see much wider use than it does.